Tiptoeing through the
T.U.L.I.P.
Summaries, Analysis, and Responses
James Patrick Holding
For the convenience of the reader we are putting together
this summary item on TULIP which will also serve as a nexus point for further
analyses. Note that this summary is NOT a full analysis and if you want to
address, inquire of, or refute any of this material, you need to read the full
articles linked below.
-
Total Depravity -- on
this one we essentially agree with the standard Calvinist position that no
person can come to Christ without assistance from God. We did not find
that the doctrine was as clearly taught in many of the usual cites in
favor, but it is nevertheless there.
-
Unconditional Election
-- a "neither side is right" finding on this one. In our view
"election" takes place in terms of primary causality: God
chooses to make this world and thereby also chooses all events that take
place within it. Since it is not logically possible to create a world in
which all will be saved, the very choice of God to make this world
constitutes a sovereign choice for the elect and non-elect.
-
Limited Atonement -- a
somewhat positive finding for the doctrine of limited atonement. Actually
it's more like a "what difference does it make" finding. One way
or the other, the elect are the only ones for whom Christ's death will
have been efficacious, so why ask about the non-elect in this regard?
-
Irresistible Grace -- a
somewhat negative finding for the doctrine of irresistible grace. In light
of our finding on unconditional election, and the parallel use of the
terms "grace" and "faith" in the New Testament world,
we conclude that God's grace may indeed be offered to all; but that can
only be said with certainty in terms of the elect.
-
Perseverance of the Saints
-- a mildly negative finding for the doctrine of eternal security. We
conclude that no sin will ever get you kicked out of the kingdom, but that
a definitive rejection of the covenant will -- and it is very, very hard
to do that!
Here's a look at some of the key verses in this arena not
covered in essays above.